Vickie Guerrero announced the double main event of Ryback vs. Paul Heyman in an NYC Street Fight and John Zcena vs. Dolph Ziggler in a steel cage.
(1) New Age Outlaws (Billy Gunn & Jesse James) beat Cody Rhodes & Damien Sandow. James commented to Cody, "Nice mustache," and Gunn said although the current WWE is PG, this is NYC, so if you're not down with that... Sandow then taunted James and said, "It's not '96!" For the finish, Billy pinned Rhodes with the famouser. The Outlaws are in great shape Billy's thinning hair is the only obvious sign of aging. James thanked the porno cowboy and savior of the unwashed asses after the match.
(2) Brodus Clay (w/Cameron and Naomi) beat David Otunga. After Clay pinned Otunga, Jack Swagger came out and challenged Clay.
(3) Brodus Clay beat Jack Swagger. The Funkadactyls danced with some lucky kids in the ring after the match.
(4) Divas champion Eve Torres beat Kaitlyn to retain the Divas Title. Short and sweet.
(5) Santino Marella beat Tensai with the Cobra. with the Cobra. Tensai was forced to sing "Rudolph the Red-nosed Reindeer." Tensai claimed he was Jewish and broke out into Sandler's Hanakah song. Tensai was hysterical singing, "Jews like Heyman, Roberts, and me."
(6) The Shield beat The Miz & WWE tag champions Daniel Bryan & Kane in a six-man tag match. Reigns pinned Miz after a powerbomb in a chaotic and entertaining match.
(7) The Usos beat Prime Time Players with a double Superfly splash pinning the PTPs simultaneously.
(8) U.S. champion Antonio Cesaro beat Zack Ryder to retain the U.S. Title. Cesaro won with the Neutralizer in a surprisingly good match.
(9) Ryback beat Paul Heyman in a N.Y. Street Fight. Heyman gave a great promo blistering the Knicks and Rangers before the match. The Shield jumped Ryback, so Team Hell No chased them off. Heyman moved in on Ryback, but was Shell-shocked immediately. Ryback left and returned to the ring to put Heyman through a table.
(10) John Cena pinned Dolph Ziggler (w/A.J. & Big E. Langston) in a steel cage match. Langston closed the door on Cena like Terry Gordy, but Cena recovered and hit the AA on Ziggler.
The Garden was shy of a sell-out, as there were many empty seats on the upper level. Overall, an entertaining show.